Malazan Character Analysis: Coltaine

Race: Human (Wickan)

Sex: Male

Faction: Malazan Empire

Overall Rating: 7.9

Alignment: Lawful Good

Arena Status: Active (S1)

In Malazan Book of the Fallen, few characters resonate with the stoic grandeur and undeniable magnetism of Coltaine, the Wickan Fist.

Fist Coltaine, Malaz 7th Army

With the sweeping landscape of the Malazan world populated by an ensemble of intricate characters, each playing their role in the grand narrative, Coltaine's impact is both visceral and enduring. This is an exploration into the depths of the enigma that is Coltaine, his journey through the books, and the legacy that lingers like an echoing war drumbeat.

Spoiler Alert: The following delves deep into the plot, revealing major events associated with Coltaine. Proceed with caution.

Deadhouse Gates, the second novel of the series, serves as the crucible where Coltaine's character is both forged and tested. Entrusted with the daunting task of leading the Chain of Dogs—a harrowing march of Malazan refugees across the continent of Seven Cities amidst a violent rebellion—Coltaine’s tactical genius and indomitable spirit are vividly displayed. This journey is not merely a physical march, but a test of endurance, strategy, and leadership.

"We are not yet done with this. We are Malazan. We remain resolute. We do not falter. We do not break." Such are the words and spirit that exemplify Coltaine's resolve.

His leadership is not merely about military strategy; it's an embodiment of sacrifice, camaraderie, and an unwavering commitment to his soldiers and the refugees. Readers witness Coltaine's astute ability to turn seemingly insurmountable odds into strategic advantages, leveraging the very landscape as a weapon against his pursuers. His Wickan heritage, with its mystical elements and fierce warrior code, further elevates the narrative.

Yet, for all his genius, Coltaine’s journey is replete with betrayal. The culmination of his arc in Deadhouse Gates is heartbreaking, a poignant reflection on the cost of leadership and the price of honor. In a series teeming with emotionally charged moments, Coltaine’s final stand and its aftermath are among the most profound, setting the stage for ripples that affect the entire series.

It's not merely the events of Deadhouse Gates that define Coltaine. References and reverberations of his actions, decisions, and, most significantly, his sacrifice, can be found throughout the subsequent books. Characters who have never met him speak his name with reverence; his legacy is invoked in moments of desperation and hope alike. Such is the indelible mark he leaves on the Malazan universe.

Though specific details from the WITNESS Trilogy may not be elaborated upon here, it’s worth noting that even in sequels and spin-offs, the ghost of Coltaine's legacy looms large. The mere acknowledgment of his continued influence underscores the depth and breadth of his character's impact.

Characters like Coltaine serve as beacons, their tales resonating with universal themes of honor, sacrifice, and resilience. In the echoing corridors of Malazan history, Coltaine’s march, his Chain of Dogs, reverberates as a haunting melody—a testament to leadership in the face of overwhelming odds, a symbol of hope when all seems lost.

As we delve deeper into his character, remember this: Coltaine's tale is not just of a warchief leading his people. It is the story of Malazan itself, a narrative where every heartbeat, every drop of sweat and blood, contributes to the grand saga. Through Coltaine, Erikson explores the very essence of what it means to lead, to sacrifice, and ultimately, to endure.

Coltaine's Raw Power

Malazan hosts a pantheon of mighty characters, each possessing their unique strengths. Coltaine of the Crow Clan, however, doesn’t manifest overt magical prowess like some of the sorcerers or ascendents of the series. Dive into the very marrow of Coltaine’s essence, and one finds a warrior born, steeped in the traditions of the Wickans. These plains people are renowned horse warriors, and their physical conditioning, honed by harsh landscapes and the demands of warfare, is exceptional. "The Wickans know how to fight," muses Duiker, the series' Imperial Historian, reflecting on the warchief's capabilities. Coltaine's raw physical strength and combat acumen, refined over countless battles, render him a force to be reckoned with on any battlefield.

However, in the grand tapestry of all fantasy universes, where characters can decimate armies with a thought, control the very elements, or transcend mortal limitations, Coltaine's raw power might seem more subdued. His strength doesn’t lie in casting vast spells or moving mountains with his mind. Instead, his power is that of tenacity, endurance, and a warrior’s spirit that refuses to yield.

Given the criteria and the vast array of characters across the fantasy spectrum, a rating of 6 for Coltaine's raw power is justifiable. He surpasses many mortal warriors but doesn't quite reach the echelons of god-like characters that populate some universes. Still, to quote the series itself, "It's not the power one has but how one wields it." And while Coltaine's raw power might rank a 6, his application of that power, his leadership, and his enduring legacy are what truly set him apart in the annals of fantasy.

Coltaine's Tactical Ability

In a realm teeming with conniving mages, ancient ascendants, and shapeshifting soletaken, Fist Coltaine emerges not through raw elemental might, but via an innate grasp of war's grand theater. His tactical acumen is an orchestration of the complex and the subtle, akin to a maestro conducting a relentless opus on the field of battle.

The “Chain of Dogs” is the most illustrious testament to Coltaine's tactical genius. This harrowing trek across the Seven Cities subcontinent sees Coltaine leading a vastly outnumbered Malazan 7th Army and thousands of refugees against relentless pursuing forces. With a multitude of tribes and their disparate tactics against him, Coltaine had to perpetually recalibrate his strategies. It's here, in the endless days of siege and skirmishes, that his brilliance unfurls.

Duiker, the Imperial Historian and witness to this epic march, poignantly remarks, “In war, it’s not about who’s right, but who’s left.” For Coltaine, it was about ensuring as many were left standing as possible, using every environmental cue, every scrap of intelligence, and turning every potential weakness into strength.

In comparison to other fantasy universes, while many characters wield grand armies or deploy cataclysmic spells, few demonstrate the finesse and tenacity required to transform a retreating caravan into a formidable fighting force. His tactics aren't mere maneuvers but an ever-evolving dance of survival and defiance.

The initial rating of 9.5 seems apt, as Coltaine’s strategies embody near-perfection within his world. Few fantasy characters, save perhaps legendary generals or beings with eons of warfare experience, could surpass him. However, there's always room for growth. A slight recalibration to a rating of 9 has been determined appropriate. While Coltaine’s tactical prowess is monumental, even he might find challenges against figures who blend tactics with reality-bending powers.

Coltaine's Influence

Within the gritty, sprawling tapestry of the Malazan Book of the Fallen, Coltaine of the Wickans emerges as a beacon of inspiration, respect, and unwavering leadership. His ability to command loyalty, galvanize disparate groups into cohesive units, and inspire hope in the direst circumstances is emblematic of his profound influence.

"Time is the only critic without ambition," muses one character within the series. And with time, Coltaine’s actions, from a strategic retreat to his ultimate sacrifice, have reverberated through the annals of history. His conduct during the Chain of Dogs, where he led a tattered army and countless refugees, showcased not just tactical brilliance but an influence that bound every soldier to the cause. He became more than a Fist; he evolved into an embodiment of endurance and commitment.

This influence isn’t merely limited to his troops. Throughout the Seven Cities, stories of Coltaine and his Wickans began to take on an almost mythological aura. Enemies respected him, allies lauded him, and those neutral to the Malazan cause couldn't deny his formidable presence.

However, what solidifies Coltaine’s influence isn't just the adoration or respect he commands, but the legacy he leaves behind. He instilled in many the belief in a cause greater than oneself, and that true leaders are defined not by power, but by the sacrifices they’re willing to make.

Given the expansive realms of fantasy fiction, where characters can influence entire worlds, realms, or even realities, placing Coltaine at an 8 seems reasonable. While his influence is monumental within his milieu, beings in other universes can sway the fabric of reality itself or manipulate the collective consciousness of entire species. However, few can claim to achieve Coltaine's depth of personal, visceral influence.

Coltaine's Resilience

Coltaine's resilience shines brightest during the harrowing events of the Chain of Dogs, where he was tasked with leading thousands of refugees and a beleaguered army across vast distances, plagued by an ever-persistent enemy and the scorching wastelands of the Seven Cities. The physical hardships of such a journey would break any ordinary man, but Coltaine's strength was undeterred. As Duiker, the Imperial Historian observes, "There is no struggle too vast, no odds too overwhelming, for even should we fail — should we fall — we will know that we have lived." Coltaine embodied this sentiment, pushing forward against escalating odds.

Yet, it is not merely physical challenges that Coltaine overcame. The psychological strain of holding together a disparate group, making hard decisions that might lead to loss, and the weight of leadership never seemed to break his spirit. His resilience in the face of internal disputes, betrayals, and sheer exhaustion became legend.

Rating him against a vast canvas of fantasy characters, some of whom have survived apocalyptic events or faced down gods, 9/10 seems appropriate for Coltaine's resilience. It's not only about enduring physical challenges but also the emotional and psychological trials that test one's mettle. A select few in other universes may showcase more overt forms of resilience, like surviving multiple deaths or overcoming cosmic forces. Still, Coltaine's resilience is rooted in raw, human tenacity, making it deeply impactful. Coltaine's resilience is as unyielding as the Wickan plains he hails from. It is a testament to the spirit of determination and the undying will to persevere, making him an epitome of human endurance in the annals of fantasy literature.

Coltaine's Versatility

Firstly, his military expertise isn't confined to traditional battlefield tactics. While his capabilities as a commander during large-scale conflicts are unquestionable, Coltaine also demonstrates a knack for guerrilla warfare, hit-and-run tactics, and siege scenarios. His strategic flexibility during the Chain of Dogs – a grueling retreat across hostile territory with a vast caravan of refugees – highlights this versatility. As noted in "Deadhouse Gates," Coltaine's ability to reorganize, adapt, and press forward despite varying challenges is masterful: "A commander's grasp of tactics can be likened to a craftsperson's hand – its value is in its adaptability, its skill when facing the unforeseen."

Beyond military strategy, Coltaine also shows adaptability in leadership. The Wickan Fist must manage an eclectic mix of personalities and races within his own army and among the refugees. This requires not just tactical prowess but also cultural sensitivity, quick thinking, and an ability to pivot his approach based on evolving circumstances.

Yet, while Coltaine's versatility is evident, it is primarily showcased within the specific crucible of the Seven Cities rebellion and not across a broader spectrum of scenarios.

Given this, a rating of 7.5/10 feels appropriate. He exceeds the previously noted 7, given the depth of his adaptability within the Chain of Dogs. However, in comparison to characters from other universes who might demonstrate versatility across multiple worlds, magic systems, or diverse challenges, Coltaine's versatility is profound but somewhat localized. Coltaine's ability to adapt to both military and leadership challenges within the Malazan universe is commendable, marking him as a figure of significant versatility, though perhaps not as broadly ranged as some other fantasy icons.

Coltaine's Alignment

Coltaine is a figure of deep complexity, a leader propelled by a sense of duty and a relentless will to protect. His actions, principles, and decisions present an intriguing debate when determining his alignment within the traditional dual axes of character determination.

Coltaine exudes an innate sense of order. His leadership during the Chain of Dogs, a tactical retreat across inhospitable lands, showcases a methodical approach to warfare and command. Even amidst the chaos of rebellion and treachery, Coltaine adheres to a code: to protect the refugees in his charge and ensure as many lives are saved as possible. However, his tactics occasionally require unpredictable maneuvers, not bound by traditional warfare etiquette but always in service to a greater, structured goal. Thus, Lawful best describes his disposition on this axis.

Coltaine’s intent is inherently noble. His mission is not one of personal gain but of sacrifice and duty. He lays down his life, and the lives of his loyal Wickan cavalry, for the sake of refugees—many of whom distrust or even despise him due to his Wickan heritage. His actions are driven by a selfless desire to preserve life and uphold the tenets of the Malazan Empire, even in the face of betrayal. Though the world of Malazan often blurs the lines of morality, making it challenging to label any character strictly, Coltaine's consistent selflessness and dedication lean towards Good on this axis.

 Coltaine operates within a structured code and consistently places the welfare of others above himself, making choices that, while tough, are always tilted towards the greater good, resulting in a Lawful Good alignment. Pride and Prophecy keeps an updated character alignment matrix across all planes of existence.

Coltaine Arena Art

Fist Coltaine Visits Casterly Rock

Coltaine's Trophy Case

PPET Rankings

Season	Rank
1 (2023-2024)	#25 (of 107)

Titles & Postseason Results

Season	Result	All Time Occurence
1 (2023-2024)	Grand Championship Bid (#7 Seed)	1st
1 (2023-2024)	Grand Championship 2nd Round Appearance (#7 Seed)	1st

Overall Conclusion on Coltaine and Position Across Planes of Existence

Within the vast tapestry of fantasy characters across myriad universes, Coltaine stands as a formidable figure, a beacon of leadership, sacrifice, and undying spirit. This evaluation places him at a rating of 7.9, a testament to his exceptional strengths but also an acknowledgment that there are entities and characters in the fantasy realm who possess power that transcends mortal limitations.

One cannot discuss Coltaine without emphasizing his indomitable spirit and leadership during the Chain of Dogs. Leading a beleaguered army, facing overwhelming odds, and ensuring the safety of tens of thousands of refugees, his feats in the Malazan Book of the Fallen are nothing short of legendary. His strategic genius and resilience, especially when faced with betrayal from within, further solidifies his place among the ranks of revered fantasy leaders.

Yet, for all his strengths, Coltaine is fundamentally mortal. He does not wield the god-like powers seen in characters from other universes, nor does he have the innate ability to alter the fabric of reality as some might. It's this humanity, coupled with his accomplishments, that endears him to readers, but it also sets a ceiling on his raw power when compared universally.

Steven Erikson's writing, however, leaves a wealth of potential for Coltaine's legacy. Given the unresolved fates of characters like Korbolo Dom and Mallick Rel, there's a sense of a story left unfinished. Erikson has shown a penchant for intricate, layered storytelling where characters thought gone can return, and destinies are often not what they seem. Thus, the possibility of redemption or further exploration of Coltaine's influence cannot be discounted in future novels.

However, this ranking is based on available material, and while Coltaine's feats are undeniably impressive, they don't quite propel him to the absolute zenith of power seen in some fantasy universes. Still, it's essential to note that power isn't solely about magical might or divine intervention. Sometimes, the most profound impacts come from characters who, despite their mortal limitations, leave an indelible mark on their world and its inhabitants. Coltaine's legacy, his choices, and the ripples they create in the Malazan world are testament to a different kind of power—one of spirit, will, and undying determination.

In conclusion, while Coltaine's 7.9 rating might not place him in the highest echelons of fantastical omnipotence, it cements him as a character whose influence, leadership, and legacy are unparalleled in many respects. As with all characters in expansive universes, the door always remains ajar for future exploration and, perhaps, a re-evaluation of his standing among the pantheon of fantasy legends. Pride and Prophecy keeps an updated power ranking across all planes of existence. This will only be sortable on desktop viewing. The below table shows a summary within the same plane of existence of this article.